A daily review of books worth your time
Advertisement
More like this
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices may vary.
Gwen Florio's BEST LAID PLANS opens a cozy mystery series with a heroine who's just torched her old life at fifty. Nora Best has swapped a faithless marriage for an Airstream and a cross-country escape, but a night at a Wyoming campground goes wrong, a man vanishes, and Nora finds herself the prime suspect in his apparent murder.
The Review
There's a particular pleasure in a mystery that starts with a personal catastrophe rather than a corpse, and Florio leans into it. The opening beat lands hard: Nora discovers her supposedly ideal husband betraying her at the very party meant to send the two of them off into retirement adventure. She bolts, hauling a trailer she barely knows how to tow, and that small detail does a lot of quiet work. It tells you this is a woman improvising her entire life in real time, which makes her a satisfying amateur to follow once the actual crime arrives.
The shape of the story is classic cozy with a road-trip twist. Nora's flight strands her at a mountain campground run by a couple named Brad and Miranda. A night of commiserating drinks turns into a morning of panic when Brad is gone and the ground around the site tells an ugly story. From there Florio works the familiar engine of the genre. An outsider stumbles into a small place, gets blamed, and has to clear her own name, all filtered through Nora's specific predicament. She's untethered, unfamiliar with the terrain, and abruptly the most convenient suspect anyone could ask for. That isolation gives the suspense a real pulse without ever tipping into anything grisly.
The Wyoming setting earns its keep. The openness of the country mirrors how exposed Nora is, with nowhere familiar to retreat to and no one obliged to take her side. Florio uses the campground's smallness against her heroine too, turning a place that should feel restful into a closing trap. The early chapters spend more time on Nora's wrecked marriage and the emotional aftermath than on the missing man, but that groundwork is doing something. By the time the trouble lands, you actually care what happens to her.
As a series opener it's juggling two jobs: resolving this disappearance and setting Nora up for whatever comes down the road. For the most part it manages both without feeling like one long prologue. The investigation tightens as Nora grasps how few allies she has, and the pacing stays brisk once the search begins. I won't speak to how the solution resolves, but the setup is fair-minded and the threat stays grounded in Nora's circumstances rather than reaching for shock.
Florio seems most interested in building a heroine, not just a sleuth, and that's worth knowing going in. If you come to cozies for the puzzle above all else, the early stretch's focus on heartbreak and reinvention may test your patience before the crime properly kicks off. But it's also the reason the danger means something when it lands, and it leaves you curious where the Airstream rolls next.
Reviewed by Quinn
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices may vary.