A daily review of books worth your time
Advertisement
More like this
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices may vary.
J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit follows Bilbo Baggins, a hobbit who wants nothing more than a quiet life, as he's dragged out his front door and onto a road that leads to a dragon's treasure. It's a cozy-then-perilous quest fantasy, funny and frightening by turns, and surprisingly tender about what courage actually costs an ordinary person.
The Review
I first read this aloud to my nephew over a long string of bedtimes, and what struck me wasn't the dragon or the gold. It was how patient Tolkien is with a character who doesn't want to be in the story at all. The Hobbit opens in a warm hole in the ground, with a respectable fellow whose biggest worry is whether there's enough cake for his unexpected guests, and then a wizard knocks. What follows is one of the cleanest adventure structures ever written: a reluctant traveler, a long road east, a string of self-contained dangers, and a hoard at the end of it. Tolkien moves Bilbo through trolls and goblins and giant spiders, and each leg of the trip works almost like its own campfire tale, complete in itself but nudging the company a little closer to the mountain.
What keeps the journey from feeling like a checklist is the voice. Tolkien narrates with a dry, fireside humor, an aside here, a wink there, a habit of letting you know when Bilbo is being foolish and when he's braver than he realizes. That tone does real work. It makes the genuinely scary parts hit harder by contrast. The scene in the dark, the riddle contest with a slippery creature in the deep places of the earth, is the best example. It starts almost as a parlor game and tightens into something clammy and dangerous, with an opponent whose loneliness and menace you feel in equal measure. The world here is built less through lore dumps than through texture: place-names, the smell of a goblin tunnel, the feel of an Elvish hall. You believe the map because you've walked it.
The heart of the book is Bilbo's slow change, and Tolkien refuses to rush it. He doesn't turn a homebody into a hero overnight. Bilbo earns each ounce of nerve, usually through cleverness rather than a blade, and his best moments come near the end, when the question stops being about gold and starts being about what sort of person he wants to be. That shift, from treasure hunt to a quiet argument about greed and loyalty and the cost of winning, is what lifts the whole thing above a simple romp. And the dragon, when he finally appears, is worth the wait. Vain, sly, terrifying, more conversationalist than brute. The chapters where Bilbo talks to him are the best in the book.
As a reading experience it's brisk and self-contained, which matters if you're weighing it against the much denser Lord of the Rings. The Hobbit is shorter, lighter on its feet, and aimed partly at younger readers, though it never talks down to them. The prose is plainer and more playful than the trilogy that followed, and the stakes stay personal and local until the final movement, when the wider world comes crashing in. If you want Tolkien's sweeping mythic gravity from page one, this isn't quite that book yet. It's the doorway, and a delightful one.
Decades on, it still reads as one of the sturdiest blueprints in the genre, and it holds up because it never forgets why the journey matters. It's about a small person finding he had more in him than anyone guessed, and about going home different than you left. I've read it to a child, read it alone on a wet afternoon, and read it as a warm-up before tackling the rings. It rewards all three.
Reviewed by Rowan
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices may vary.